Gas vs. Electric: Which Hot Water System is Right for Your Home?

Shower head with hot water

When it comes to the comfort of your home, a reliable and efficient hot water system is non-negotiable. However, choosing the right hot water system for your home can be a challenging decision if you are unsure what best fits the needs of your home. This guide highlights the pros and cons of both gas and electric hot water systems, along with key factors to consider, helping you make a smart, long-term investment in your home’s hot water solution.

Gas Hot Water System

Gas hot water systems use a gas burner to heat water, which is then either delivered instantly as needed or stored in a tank.

Pros

  • Lower Running Costs: When using natural gas, gas hot water systems have lower running costs and contribute to more savings on your energy bills.
  • Fast Heating: Gas burners generate heat at a higher level, making them more efficient at heating water quickly.  
  • Continuous Flow: Rather than storing hot water in a tank, gas hot water systems provide a continuous flow of hot water as it travels through a heat exchanger.

Cons

  • Requires Gas Connection: Your home must be connected to a natural gas line to integrate a gas hot water system
  • Higher Upfront Costs: Gas hot water systems tend to have higher installation costs as they require a licensed gas plumber or fitter to install gas lines if your property does not have existing gas line connections.
  • Potential Heat Loss: Storage tank models can lose some heat over time due to potential buildup acting as insulation.

Electric Hot Water System 

Electric hot water systems use an electric heating element to heat up water in an insulated tank, holding the heated water until it is ready for use. 

Pros 

  • Lower Upfront Costs: As electric hot water systems have a simpler set-up, they tend to be easier and cheaper to install.
  • Simple and Accessible: Electric hot water systems are more accessible as they can be installed in most locations and are ideal for fitting into smaller spaces.
  • Lower Maintenance: With a simpler set-up, electric hot water systems generally require less maintenance. 

Cons

  • Higher Running Costs: Electric hot water systems can use a significant amount of electricity, leading to higher costs in the long run.
  • Vulnerable to Power Outages: As the system relies on electricity to run, it will not work during a power outage.
  • Slower Recovery: If the hot water supply is depleted, the tank can take a long time to reheat, which may be inefficient for high-demand households.

Factors to Consider for Your Home

  • Household Size: Your household size directly impacts hot water demand. For high-demand households, a gas hot water system is the recommended option as it has a quicker reheat time and a more continuous flow.  
  • Energy Efficiency: Both gas and electrical hot water systems can achieve excellent energy ratings. However, electrical systems have a significant advantage for homes that have solar panels installed.
  • Home Infrastructure: The infrastructure of your home is an important factor when choosing a system. Electric hot water systems are a better option for homes that have space constraints or do not have a gas line. 
  • Upfront Costs vs. Long-Term Savings: Upfront and long-term running costs are a crucial factor to consider, as the initial cheaper option could end up costing you more.

Wondering how you can maximise long-term savings on your water bill? Read our blog on How to Reduce Your Hot Water Costs.

Your Local Hot Water System Experts

At Plumbers and Gasfitters Bunbury, we are experts in both gas and electrical hot water systems. With 24/7 services, our team is always available to assist with all your hot water and plumbing needs. We know the important role of an efficient hot water system in every household, which is why we provide regular servicing on your hot water system, keeping your unit well-maintained and your water bills low. Contact us today for reliable and professional plumbing in Bunbury and Davenport.

Read more on our other blogs:

Excellent
David M.
Jeremy Stevens was professional and extremely efficient from start to finish. He done an exceptional job installing and connecting our new hot water system. I would highly recommend to anyone wanting to get their plumbing solutions sorted. 10/10
Meeeii
After making an appointment, they arrived at my home the next morning and helped me quickly deal with the blocked drains. The employees were very polite, proactive and serious in solving the problem for me. If I have any problems at home in the future, I will decide to come back again. them and highly recommend them
Ann-Kathrin Y.
Great service, prompt and reliable! The staff are very polite, knowledgeable and very helpful and the prices are reasonable. Would recommend them anytime!!
Lasitha J.
Excellent service with excellent value
on time
Kris V.
Quick to come out and fix water leak and professional service would highly recommend
Nola S.
Linda K.
We have had these guys out to our place three times for different issues. Each time the attending plumber (Jeremy) has arrived on time and attended to the work efficiently and professionally. In fact, he identified an issue that another tradie had missed! Great work and highly recommended.
Alex E.
Lynne C.
Thank you. Wonderful service. Great price.
Tanya A.
Karen C.
I would recommend Luke and his team for all your plumbing needs. Prompt, polite and professional 5 stars! Very pleased with their service.
Kelli P.
A massive thanks to Luke and his team. They are always available to help, find the issue and fix the problem. They turn up when they say they are going to which is an added bonus. Nothing to big or small. 5 stars from me 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Tim S.
Spoke to the owner Luke in the morning about a leak in the roof space. He sent one of his workers around the same day to repair and install a new copper line and garden tap. Jeremy was polite and did a professional job. Thanks guys.
Sue W.
Luke was totally brilliant. He attended my property on the same day that I called and rectified the fault very quickly and professionally. I highly recommend his services.
Coenraad Adolf E.
Fast and friendly service.
Bernie L.
Luke was excellent....his response was very quick and he did a good job with the problem with my hot water unit...what I liked the most was his quick response and above all his honesty
Amy
Top quality work and friendly service
Teagan J.
They did an awesome job and very friendly staff too!
Gareth K.
5 stars from me, recently had theses guys out to fix my blocked toilet came out at midnight too. Would recommend them to anybody 👍👍
Sharlene G.
Great service and great value
Nat & Shaun R.
Grant T.
Good guys to deal with.
Jeremy H.
Great guys
Great prices
And very professional
Luke V.
Nel
Great service - extremely helpful with all my questions
Kylie S.
© 2026 Plumbers and Gasfitters Bunbury. All Rights Reserved. Digital Marketing by Daisy Digital